"plus she doesn’t like writing hetero relationships that much. Well that shows mostly through her writing."?
Anonymous
Most of the time in her fics, particularly LIFE series, male characters are villains or family members or both if you’ve read FAMILY.
Her attempts at heterosexual relationships for her characters are rare.
Jessica is her bias and she always posts Taengsic. She’s said herself that Taeyeon in LIFE series is a lot like herself. So I highly doubt that she could write a GB with any member being born a boy.
With the exception of the character suffering from a gender identity crises and then going through the process of realising their gender identity either boy or girl.
what makes you believe rayanne won't write a gb?
Anonymous
Well she has stated before that she doesn’t like gb plus she doesn’t like writing hetero relationships that much. Well that shows mostly through her writing.
Hi ^__^ I just wanted to say that I completely agree with your thoughts on gender bender fics. And the anon completely missed the point. Yes, writers have the freedom to write whatever they want and people also have the freedom to like whatever they want. If you want to write boy / girl fics, write them all you want. But use real life males. Or as you said, if you want to write e.g a TaengSic fic and make Tae a male, then at least give it a good reasoning.
“TBC ask part 1: Plus, when you change the gender of one of the members then what you wrote stops being a fanfic and starts being merely fiction. And as you said, then you might as well change everything else. Their names, their ethnicity, their habits, everything. If you really ship e.g. TaengSic, you’ll write a fic about Taeyeon and Jessica, not some random dorky male and Jessica. And in case you want to write a fic about some random dorky male with Jessica, then at least don’t call it a TaengSic fic.
Part 2: Because it’s not. Because Taeyeon is not a guy. If you claim to ship TaengSic or any other girl x girl pairing, but you only read/write GB fics then you have some serious heteronormative / homophobic issues. Just look at yourself and think “Why do I like reading GB fics and not femslash? If I’m supposedly a shipper then why I can’t read a fic about them when one of the girls isn’t a guy”.”
My answer:
Exactly and I stated those points but they didn’t seem to notice. Some people just can’t seem to be reasoned with.
im not here to fan the fuel but curiousity has gotten the best of me. so i wonder you said auratus and rayanne are a few of your fav writers. auratus has written gb but has done it well with tiffany/timothy. but what if rayanne came out with a gb and had one of the girls be boys from the start? would you stop being her fan? or if auratus's gb switch with tiffany/timothy didn't make sense would you stop reading shoch?
Anonymous
for one Rayanne wouldn’t do gb.
Tbh when I first read shoch I stopped reading for few weeks when I got to the Tiffany/Timothy part. I’ll admit it is done well but I’m still irked by it.
will i pass up on a fic that's better than auratus' or endymion's works only because they're not girls there? i read anything that i find interesting. seems to me like you really think you're a relevant sone lmao what a pity
Anonymous
Now you presume to know what I think.
I do not consider Auratus to be the best I have read better fics than his.
What does Endymion have to do with this?
oh and i don't really care if it's genderbender, if it's full of fluff, if the writer kills one of the girls in the story. as long as i can read and i like it, it's fine with me. you don't have to be fine with that. i don't need to explain why i like something
Anonymous
But need to explain why I don’t like something?
Sorry but you can’t have it that way. If I’m going to defend my opinion you damn well better be prepared to defend yours. Or is it that you don’t have your own thoughts?
Please enlighten me or are incapable of doing so?
explain what? why people prefer one thing over another? personal preference, never heard of it? don't hate on people who like something that you despise. i like how you refer to someone who disagrees with your opinion (that you think is right in your head, still laughing at this) as an anti. jesus christ can't you stand on your own feet? at least quote the damn thing when it's not your words. i don't want you to come crawling to auratus anymore i'm done. i respect him, can't say the same to you
Anonymous
I haven’t actually quoted him in over 24 hrs and even then it was only for those asked and one post.
I have explained my opinion and I do not want nor need the respect of a grey-face.
To the rest of my followers; May I know your thoughts on this? So far it’s only this anon they want me to stop I presume but I wont if they wont.
no need to drag auratus in this and why are you using his replies as your replies? do you not have your own thoughts? let me ask you this, do you think because of what you're doing you're a better fan the rest of the fandom who like genderbenders? do you consider your kind the majority of the fandom? your last words lol i should be saying that. look at your answers. some are from auratus. auratus is a good writer but like us he's still just a fan, we're all on the same boat
Anonymous
I don’t consider myself part of the majority.
Yes I have my own thoughts but lots of people have difficulty giving words to those thoughts. Is it wrong to use the words of others to give voice to our thoughts? If so then we should think less of those who, like you are with me.
Better fan; no I don’t think so.
Though you’ve gone on and on defending gender bending but can’t tell me what makes it good and since, on AFF at least, they are more popular than non gender bending fics.
Explain then.
yea sarcasm doesn't become me, but elitism sure does become you.
Anonymous
Elitism:
Noun
- The advocacy or existence of an elite as a dominating element in a system or society.
- The attitude or behavior of a person or group who regard themselves as belonging to an elite.
Since I appear to be in the minority here then the first definition does not apply.
The second definition; I do not regard my self as part of an elite.
Where does that you leave you?
it's super pointless trying to talk to someone who thinks his/her opinion is correct in his/her own head. good luck on your quest of obliterating genderbender fics and sucking out the fun some people have reading them. that's a lost cause. it's funny how you talk about respect for artists that you like but be disrespectful for fans who are just writing genderbenders because they wanted to. snsd will SURELY be proud of you. lol
Anonymous
Our own opinions are correct. An opinion by definition is:
Noun
- A view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.
- The beliefs or views of a large number or majority of people about a particular thing.
Try Auratus ask if you want more. I grow tired of you bleating.
Auratusauram
you're right. now I see the light. thanks.
Anonymous
Sarcasm doesn’t become you Grey-face.
“I get that some writers can be homophobes or uncomfortable with shipping girl/girl. That’s okay.” it's not okay. not okay. you said it i didn't. i reiterate being a homophobe is not okay. "opinion is right in our own heads" LMAO that's how narrow-minded people think you only care about your opinion because in your head it's right. jesus christ you're beyond being an elitist
Anonymous
Our opinions are right in our own head. What matters is if you respect others opinions. You have not given me a reason to respect yours since you do not even have the decency to give a face to your opinion.
